Welcome to More Frosting Please! Sweet Shoppe

Click here to edit subtitle

More Frosting Please! Sweet Shoppe * 125 E. Mill St, Plymouth, WI * [email protected]

Welcome to our website! More Frosting Please! is a family owned business in Plymouth, WI. We not only offer a storefront shop where you can come in to purchase desserts, but we also offer classes as well as create special order cupcakes, cookies, peanut squares, cakes and more. 

From exquisitely tiered wedding cakes with intricate floral designs to baby-shower cakes decorated with delicate hues of pink or blue to birthday cakes stylized with dazzling designs-every cake that we make tastes as good as it looks. Every special occasion is an occasion for delicious cake!


Celebrating a special event with a delicious cake is the best way to create sweet memories. Using personalized cake designing, we bake and decorate a cake that reflects your personal taste. Delicious flavors, frosting tinted to any color, and personalized cake decorating ensures our customer’s satisfaction each and every time.


Choose from a wide assortment of custom cake flavors and frosting for a one-of-a-kind delight that provides your guest of honor with a memorable event. With a goal of making every special occasion sweeter one slice at a time, we give new meaning to the word scrumptious making every cake fresh from the finest ingredients. 


Please feel free to browse through our large selection of flavors and fillings at the tab above. If you can’t seem to find the design that you’re looking for, it’s only because we haven’t created it yet! At More Frosting Please, we love the challenge of creating a custom wedding or specialty cake to fit your style and taste. Allow our creative staff to customize a cake for your special event. Or, if you see a cake on another website, please email the website or picture to us and we will work with you to make your vision come true. Be sure to honor copyrighted photos by crediting the creator as well.


125 E. Mill St
Plymouth, WI 53073
WEDS: 9am-5pm
THURSDAY- 9am-5pm
FRIDAY 9am-4pm
SATURDAY 9am-3pm